Friday, March 9, 2012

In chapter six Ester criticizes Mrs. Jellyby's priorities.  Ester suggest that although Mrs. Jellyby's Africa project is noble, she should focus on her home before devoting herself to things outside the home. She says on page 113, "... it is right to begin with the obligations of home, sir; and that, perhaps while those are overlooked and neglected, no other duties can possibly be substituted for them?" Ester falls in line with the Victorian Idea that a woman's place is in the home and that should be her first and most important priority. I'm wondering if Dickens is suggesting there is a loss of this as there is more than one example of a woman who's family seems out of sorts because of her devotion to another cause. A good example is Mrs. Pardiggle, her boy's as Ester says were, "...such dissatisfied children"(Dickens, 143). Dickens suggest with these two characters that women should not be focused on things outside the home or their home and children will suffer. What does everyone else think of this idea. Do you think Dickens wanted women to stay home.

2 comments:

  1. Have you read the scene in the book where Caddy gets sick and Esther nurses her for quite a while? In her narration, she makes it clear that she only goes to Caddy after her duties at home are done (and John Jarndyce comments, I think, that he really didn't even know she was gone, implying that she still kept the house in order). This is sort of what I was talking about when we discussed your abstract. Part of the problem is definitely that the female characters are focused outside the home, but I almost think that's secondary--in terms of flaws--to their not taking care of business at home. If Esther can handle both well, other women should be able to as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I kind of agree but kind of don't with this idea. I don't think that Dickens wanted to stay home I think he wanted to show the effect that not paying attention to your home 'duties' as well as work ones will be a problem for your entire family. For example I’ll use Mrs. Jellyby she focuses so much on her work that she doesn’t pay attention to anything that her daughter is telling her. Instead she says something like “If I wasn’t so busy this would bother me” and stuff like that rather than actually dealing with what is going on in her own household.

    ReplyDelete